murphyandhislaw

reading list

We

Yevgeny Zamyatin

published: 1924, read: 9/7/25
226 pages, genre: Sci-Fi
rating: 7/10, normalized: 6.667/10
-0.23σ worse than average
0.016σ or 0.015/10 better than average in Sci-Fi genre

Didn’t appear in russia till 1988 because Soviet cultural authorities had a nose for heresy second only to the curia herself

The benefactor is a pretty transparentl stand-in for Joseph Stalin thus resulting in some fun publishing antics akin to The Gulag Archipelago

see also his essay on the infinity of revolution like numbers

kissing her then telling her about the beauty of the square, the cube, and the straight line. D-503 my goat

D-503 is a mathematician in the 26th century assigned to date O-90, but in love with I-33, friend/jealous of the poet R-13

Muses about how people lived in isolation before the 200 years war. Presumably they must have had tails.

3

Can't wait for everything to be set in the table of hours, looking forward to the rigidity of the table of seconds.

Refuses nuptials with O-90 because it's not the right day yet

4

People are numbers, not names. Not just that their names are numbers, but their very identities are these identifiers.

D-503 finds it ridiculous that government of One state (population 10 million) didn't proscribe life / sex. People lived like animals instead of by science

Respected numbers! Our archeologists have recently dug up a certain twentieth-century book in which the ironic author tells the story of a savage and a barometer. The savage noticed that every time the barometer indicated ‘rain/ it actually rained. And since he wanted it to rain, he picked out exactly enough mercury from the column to leave it at “rain.’” (On the screen—a savage, dressed in feathers, picking out the mercury. Laughter.) “You are laughing. But does it not seem to you that the European of that period was even more ridiculous? Like the savage, the European wanted ‘rain’—rain with a capital letter, algebraic rain. But all he did was stand before the barometer like a limp wet hen. The savage, at least, had more courage and energy and logic, if only primitive logic He had been able to discover that there was a connection between effect and cause. Picking out the mercury, he was able to take the first step on that great road along which …

5

Describes the One state's conquest first of hunger, the algebraic summit of existence, before attacking the next greatest foe: love – defeated via systemization.

Well. One of the ancient sages said a clever thing—accidentally, of course—“Love and Hunger rule the world.” Ergo: to conquer the world, man must conquer its rulers. Our forebears succeeded, at heavy cost, in conquering Hunger; I am speaking of the Great Two Hundred Years’ War—the war between the city and the village. The primitive peasants, prompted perhaps by religious prejudice, stubbornly clung to their “bread.” * But in the year 85 before the founding of the One State, our present food, a petroleum product, was developed. True, only 0.2 of the earth’s population survived the war. But, cleansed of its millennial filth, how radiant the face of the earth has become! And those two tenths survived to taste the heights of bliss in the shining palace of the One State.

6

the personal hour is set aside for unforeseen consequences (implied: not leisure).

Describes his aversion to communal living and jealousy of other's sex-day ticket.

7

Has an unscheduled encounter with I-330 where she says something about knowing the "real" him before disappearing from the apartment. He chalks this up to something similar to that ancient sickness of dreaming

9

Describes the execution of a poet who dared "blaspheme" (mildly) the One state:

Poet, mocker (laughter, he wrote, is the most devastating weapon), heretical fighter for freedom and independence in art and in life, Zamyatin was a consistent enemy of all canonized ideas, all coercion, all the purveyors of “compulsory salvation.” He mercilessly attacked and ridiculed the emerging totalitarianism, its fawning mediocrities, its reign of brutality, its violation and destruction of the free and creative human spirit He foresaw it all: the terror, the betrayals, the dehumanization; the ubiquitous “guardians”; the control of thought and action; the constant brainwashing which resulted either in unquestioning automatons or in hypocrites who lied for the sake of survival; the demand that everybody worship the Benefactor, with his huge hand that literally “liquidates,” reduces all who dissent, all who passionately want to be themselves to a puddle of clear water. He also foresaw the subjection of the arts. His hero boasts: “We have harnessed the once wild element of poetry. Today, poetry is no

R13 responsible for versifying the verdict of the execution of the man earlier

13

"all women are lips, nothing but lips"

There are two modes for D-503 the outward presenting one which praises the one-state and says shit like this^^ and then the interior human one which is less rational, more emotional. ironically, the emotional one gives way to these pangs of anger at women which then manifest outwardly as complaints about violations of order longer the idle, impudent whistling of a nightingale; poetry is civic service, poetry is useful.” And not only must the people (“numbers”) in this apocalyptic state of ritualized totalitarianism attend the gala ceremony of extermination of every heretic by the Benefactor, but a poet is obliged to recite an ode celebrating the wisdom and great justice of the executioner.

14

Hooks up with O (impregnating her), but lets something hurtful slip out about his preference for I-3300. Blames I for taking R-13 and O-90 away from him.

Things that are controlled are "clear" like the glass that everything is made out of. I-330, on the other hand, a mystery, is opaque.

15

He's working on a spaceship called the Integral

Generally writing for other planetary beings to be colonized by his ship (earlier he lamented the difficulty of not writing for the past or present audiences, but knew unknown ones)

The coital cubes are opaque – that's the only time privacy is permitted

ego = "I" = i = sqrt(-1), anethema to One state

16

finds his way into medical (thinking he might instead be caught up in operations for skipping work to bang I-330) and throws himself at a doctor saying something about dreams & insomnia. Dr says:

“You’re in a bad way! Apparently, you have developed a soul.”

22

"we" comes from God, "I" the devil.

At the normally unanimous elections, some few thousand people dissent against the reelection of the benefactor and insanity/a riot breaks out. D-503 sees R-13 carrying I-33 away, as well as O-90 (who is now pregnant with his child), getting just about trampled to death. He pursues I, hits R, and is somehow at peace with the disorder because at least he's clutcher her (I) to his chest.

related

ReadAuthorTitlePagesPublishedGenreRatingRating'TagsRecommended by
9/7/25Yevgeny ZamyatinWe2261924Sci-Fi7.0006.667
9/10/25George Orwell19843281949Sci-Fi7.7507.500
"dystopia"anti-soviet propaganda
9/6/25Aldous HuxleyBrave New World2881932Sci-Fi7.2506.944
"dystopia"anti-soviet propaganda
9/14/25Kurt VonnegutPlayer Piano2961952Sci-Fi6.6506.278
"dystopia"
7/31/26Mikhail BulgakovHeart of a Dog 1231968Fiction7.3507.056
anti-soviet propaganda
Zack B.
6/6/26Mikhail BulgakovThe Master and Margarita4501967Fiction7.6507.389
anti-soviet propaganda
4/27/26Jean RaspailThe Camp of the Saints3561973Fiction5.5005.000
"dystopia"
11/27/25Vladimir SorokinTheir Four Hearts2041994Fiction7.5007.222
anti-soviet propaganda
9/21/26Yoko OgawaThe Memory Police2881994Sci-Fi4.0003.333
7/1/26Vernor VingeA Fire Upon the Deep6261992Sci-Fi7.2506.944
12/31/25Cixin LiuTo Hold Up the Sky3362021Sci-Fi6.7006.333
11/9/25Greg EganDistress
Subjective Cosmology Cycle (3)
3421998Sci-Fi7.0006.667
10/29/25Greg EganQuarantine
Subjective Cosmology Cycle (1)
2801992Sci-Fi7.7507.500
10/15/25Robert A. HeinleinStarship Troopers2901987Sci-Fi8.0007.778
Charlie J.
8/11/25Greg EganDiaspora3761997Sci-Fi8.0007.778
thesephist
8/11/25Olga RavnThe Employees1262020Sci-Fi5.5005.000
6/8/25Helen PhillipsThe Need2722019Sci-Fi7.1506.833
4/7/25Pierce BrownLight Bringer
Red Rising Saga (6)
7042023Sci-Fi7.7507.500
Thomas
3/27/25Pierce BrownDark Age
Red Rising Saga (5)
7842019Sci-Fi7.5007.222
Thomas
3/18/25Pierce BrownIron Gold
Red Rising Saga (4)
5962018Sci-Fi6.0005.556
Thomas
3/18/25qntmFine Structure3862021Sci-Fi7.0006.667
3/13/25Pierce BrownMorning Star
Red Rising Saga (3)
5182016Sci-Fi5.1254.583
Thomas
3/5/25Pierce BrownGolden Son
Red Rising Saga (2)
4642015Sci-Fi5.8755.417
Thomas
2/28/25Pierce BrownRed Rising
Red Rising Saga (1)
3822014Sci-Fi5.5005.000
Thomas
2/18/25Hugh HowieDust
Silo (3)
4802013Sci-Fi7.0006.667
Jack M.
2/14/25Hugh HowieShift
Silo (2)
5762013Sci-Fi7.2506.944
Jack M.
2/9/25Hugh HowieWool
Silo (1)
5922011Sci-Fi7.0006.667
Jack M.
2/1/25Matt DinnimanDungeon Crawler Carl
Dungeon Crawler Carl (1)
4642020Sci-Fi6.0005.556
Noah
1/15/25qntmEd1442021Sci-Fi7.0006.667
1/13/25qntmValuable Humans in Transit and Other Stories1072022Sci-Fi7.3757.083
1/3/25Isaac AsimovNightfall and Other Stories3521969Sci-Fi6.7376.374
12/7/24Dan SimmonsThe Rise of Endymion
Hyperion Cantos (4)
5791997Sci-Fi6.0005.556
11/30/24Dan SimmonsEndymion
Hyperion Cantos (3)
4411996Sci-Fi6.2505.833
11/30/24George R.R. MartinDreamsongs: The Second Kind of Loneliness6701972Sci-Fi7.2506.944
11/24/24Dan SimmonsThe Fall of Hyperion
Hyperion Cantos (2)
5171990Sci-Fi8.2508.056
11/16/24Dan SimmonsHyperion
Hyperion Cantos (1)
4821989Sci-Fi8.0257.806
9/6/24Alastair ReynoldsEversion3522022Sci-Fi7.0836.759
Nick W.
9/6/24Greg EganYou and Whose Army?341998Sci-Fi6.7506.389
9/5/24Greg EganPlanck Dive231998Sci-Fi9.2509.167
9/4/24Paul AndersonTau Zero2321970Sci-Fi7.2506.944
roon
8/29/24José SaramagoBlindness3521995Sci-Fi7.0006.667
8/28/24Margaret AtwoodOryx and Crake
MaddAddam (1)
4002003Sci-Fi6.0005.556
Steg
8/1/24Ursula K. Le GuinThe Telling
Hainish Cycle (8)
4162000Sci-Fi6.5006.111
7/28/24Ursula K. Le GuinFour Ways to Forgiveness
Hainish Cycle (7)
3201995Sci-Fi5.5005.000
7/26/24Ursula K. Le GuinThe Left Hand of Darkness
Hainish Cycle (4)
3371969Sci-Fi7.5007.222
7/26/24Ursula K. Le GuinThe Word for World is Forest
Hainish Cycle (5)
1891972Sci-Fi7.7507.500
7/16/24Ursula K. Le GuinCity of Illusions
Hainish Cycle (3)
1991967Sci-Fi6.7506.389
7/10/24Ursula K. Le GuinRocannon's World
Hainish Cycle (1)
2581966Sci-Fi6.5006.111
7/10/24Ursula K. Le GuinPlanet of Exile
Hainish Cycle (2)
1351966Sci-Fi6.0005.556
6/30/24Ursula K. Le GuinThe Dispossessed
Hainish Cycle (6)
2841974Sci-Fi7.8507.611
6/14/24Philip K. DickUbik2411969Sci-Fi6.5006.111
6/14/24Philip K. DickThe Three Stigmata of Palmer Eldritch2901964Sci-Fi7.5007.222
6/13/24Neal StephensonSeveneves8802015Sci-Fi8.7508.611
6/2/24Philip K. DickFlow My Tears, the Policeman Said2591974Sci-Fi7.0636.736
5/27/24Philip K. DickA Scanner Darkly2201977Sci-Fi6.7506.389
5/22/24Philip K. DickDo Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?2741968Sci-Fi8.0007.778
5/12/24Italo CalvinoCosmicomics1791965Sci-Fi7.0296.699
Will Liff.
1/13/24Iain BanksConsider Phlebas
Culture (1)
4711987Sci-Fi6.2505.833
roon
1/1/24Arthur C. ClarkeFountains of Paradise2631979Sci-Fi7.0006.667
12/17/23James S.A. CoreyCaliban's War
The Expanse (2)
6052012Sci-Fi5.0004.444
Charlie J.
10/28/23James S.A. CoreyLeviathan Wakes
The Expanse (1)
5772011Sci-Fi6.7506.389
Charlie J.
10/14/23Roger ZelaznyLord of Light3081967Sci-Fi6.7506.389
8/23/23Adrian TchaikovskyCage of Souls6382019Sci-Fi8.0007.778
Alex W.
7/15/23Gene WolfeFifth Head of Cerberus2441972Sci-Fi9.0838.981
6/18/23VariousObsolescence3602023Sci-Fi6.0005.556
1/31/23Greg EganPermutation City
Subjective Cosmology Cycle (2)
2751994Sci-Fi6.7506.389
1/29/23George SaundersEscape from Spiderhead102010Sci-Fi7.7507.500
1/27/23Robert A. HeinleinThe Moon is a Harsh Mistress3821966Sci-Fi8.2508.056
1/18/23Adrian TchaikovskyChildren of Ruin
Children of Time (2)
4752019Sci-Fi6.7506.389
Alex W.
1/15/23Blake CrouchDark Matter3682017Sci-Fi7.0006.667
Nick W.
1/13/23Adrian TchaikovskyChildren of Time
Children of Time (1)
5132015Sci-Fi7.0006.667
Alex W.
1/11/23Ted ChiangExhalation3682019Sci-Fi7.5007.222
1/8/23Joe HaldermanThe Forever War2361974Sci-Fi5.0004.444
10/27/22Cixin LiuDeaths End
Three Body Problem (3)
5922008Sci-Fi8.5008.333
Alex W.
10/17/22Cixin LiuThe Dark Forest
Three Body Problem (2)
4002008Sci-Fi9.0008.889
Alex W.
10/10/22Isaac AsimovSecond Foundation
Foundation (4)
2101953Sci-Fi6.5006.111
10/1/22Cixin LiuThe Three Body Problem
Three Body Problem (1)
3022008Sci-Fi8.0007.778
Alex W.
9/15/22Isaac AsimovFoundation
Foundation (3)
2551951Sci-Fi6.5006.111
9/11/22Isaac AsimovForward the Foundation
Foundation (2)
4171993Sci-Fi7.0006.667
9/5/22Frank HerbertDune Messiah
Dune (2)
2561969Sci-Fi7.0006.667
9/5/22Frank HerbertChildren of Dune
Dune (3)
4441976Sci-Fi6.5006.111
8/6/22Frank HerbertDune
Dune (1)
4121965Sci-Fi7.5007.222
7/13/22Isaac AsimovPrelude to Foundation
Foundation (1)
4481988Sci-Fi6.5006.111
10/13/16Ernest ClineReady Player One3842011Sci-Fi6.5006.111
8/16/16Douglas AdamsThe Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy2241979Sci-Fi6.5006.111
4/20/16Orson Scott CardEnder's Game
Ender (1)
3241985Sci-Fi7.7507.500
6/28/13Eoin ColferThe Supernaturalist2902004Sci-Fi7.0006.667