murphyandhislaw

reading list

Arbecht Macht Frei (2): If This is a Man

Primo Levi

published: 1947, read: 7/5/26
179 pages, genre: History
rating: 7.75/10, normalized: 7.5/10
0.451σ better than average
-0.213σ or -0.242/10 worse than average in History genre
1σ or 0.125/10 better than average by Primo Levi

“You who live safe

In your warm houses,

You who find, returning in the evening,

Hot food and friendly faces:

Consider if this is a man

Who works in the mud

Who does not know peace

Who fights for a scrap of bread

Who dies because of a yes or a no.

Consider if this is a woman,

Without hair and without name

With no more strength to remember,

Her eyes empty and her womb cold

Like a frog in winter.

Meditate that this came about:

I commend these words to you.

Carve them in your hearts

At home, in the street,

Going to bed, rising;

Repeat them to your children,

Or may your house fall apart,

May illness impede you,

May your children turn their faces from you.

Death begins with the shoes:

Death begins with the shoes; for most of us, they show themselves to be instruments of torture, which after a few hours of marching cause painful sores which become fatally infected. Whoever has them is forced to walk as if he was dragging a convict’s chain (this explains the strange gait of the army which returns every evening on parade); he arrives last everywhere, and everywhere he receives blows. He cannot escape if they run after him; his feet swell and the more they swell, the more the friction with the wood and the cloth of the shoes becomes insupportable. Then only the hospital is left: but to enter the hospital with a diagnosis of ‘dicke Füsse’ (swollen feet) is extremely dangerous, because it is well known to all, and especially to the SS, that here there is no cure for that complaint

Babelian prison of being wrong, but not knowing why:

But from above and below, from near by and from far away, from all corners of the now dark hut, sleepy and angry voices shout at me: ‘Ruhe, Ruhe!’

I understand that they are ordering me to be quiet, but the word is new to me, and since I do not know its meaning and implications, my inquietude increases. The confusion of languages is a fundamental component of the manner of living here: one is surrounded by a perpetual Babel, in which everyone shouts orders and threats in languages never heard before, and woe betide whoever fails to grasp “he meaning. No one has time here, no one has patience, no one listens to you; we latest arrivals instinctively collect in the corners, against the walls, afraid of being beaten.”

Comparative levels of unhappiness:

At sunset, the siren of the Feierabend sounds, the end of work; and as we are all satiated, at least for a few hours, no quarrels arise, we feel good, the Kapo feels no urge to hit us, and we are able to think of our mothers and wives, which usually does not happen. For a few hours we can be unhappy in the manner of free men.

Similarly, levels of morality that are stripped away:

In conclusion: theft in Buna, punished by the civil direction, is authorized and encouraged by the SS; theft in camp, severely repressed by the SS, is considered by the civilians as a normal exchange operation; theft among Häftlinge is generally punished, but the punishment strikes the thief and the victim with equal gravity. We now invite the reader to contemplate the possible meaning in the Lager of the words ‘good’ and ‘evil’, ‘just’ and ‘unjust’; let everybody judge, on the basis of the picture we have outlined and of the examples given above, how much of our ordinary moral world could survive on this side of the barbed wire.

On the dignity of personhood:

We do not believe in the most obvious and facile deduction: that man is fundamentally brutal, egoistic and stupid in his conduct once every civilized institution is taken away, and that the Häftling is consequently nothing but a man without inhibitions. We believe, rather, that the only conclusion to be drawn is that in the face of driving necessity and physical disabilities many social habits and instincts are reduced to silence.

Really good profiles of some of the types of scoundrels and great men that excelled in the camps for one reason or another.

I heard myself replying with the words I had often heard spoken by the old ones of the camp, expressing their favourite boast — of being hardboiled, ‘old hands’, who always knew how to find their feet: ‘Ich verstehe verschiedene Sachen.’ I know how to do many things …

Interesting philosophy about how a man's code is like an abridged biography of his life. His decalogue informs the way that he has been treated:

It is common knowledge that nobody is born with a decalogue already formed, but that everyone builds his own either during his life or at the end, on the basis of his own experiences, or of those of others which can be assimilated to his own; so that everybody’s moral universe, suitably interpreted, comes to be identified with the sum of his former experiences, and so represents an abridged form of his biography.

related

ReadAuthorTitlePagesPublishedGenreRatingRating'TagsRecommended by
7/5/26Primo LeviIf This is a Man
Arbecht Macht Frei (2)
1791947History7.7507.500
5/31/26William L. ShirerThe Rise and Fall of the Third Reich12801960History8.7508.611
Nazis
Charlie J.
7/17/24Viktor FranklMan's Search for Meaning1651946History7.3757.083
Nazis
Penny
7/8/26Primo LeviThe Truce2531963Biography7.5007.222
6/26/26William T. VollmannEurope Central8322005Historical Fiction8.5508.389
Nazis
3/27/26Roberto BolañoThe Third Reich2771989Fiction7.7507.500
Nazis
3/25/26Roberto BolañoNazi Literature in the Americas2371996Fiction8.2508.056
Nazis
3/3/26Stefan ZweigChess841942Fiction8.5008.333
Nazis
1/30/26William H. GassThe Tunnel6521995Fiction8.5508.389
Nazis
Ben Roth
8/5/25Thomas PynchonThe Crying of Lot 491521965Fiction8.7508.611
Nazis
Preston
9/23/24John SteinbeckThe Moon is Down1261942Historical Fiction7.2506.944
Nazis
9/9/24Thomas PynchonV.5451963Fiction7.2216.912
Nazis
4/9/24Roberto Bolaño2666: A Novel9122004Fiction8.1507.944
Nazis
roon
7/6/23Dan SimmonsCarrion Comfort8021989Horror8.5638.403
Nazis
1/20/22Stephen KingThe Apt Pupil2241998Horror6.0005.556
Nazis
Jack M.
10/10/26Ali WatkinsThe Next One is For You3362025History7.7507.500
6/2/26Alfred LansingEndurance4161959History7.7507.500
Jack M.
4/30/26Ben R. RichSkunk Works: A Personal Memoir of My Years at Lockheed3721994History7.7507.500
3/17/26Maurice Finocchiaro The Galileo Affair3981989History9.0008.889
2/20/26Rufus JonesSpiritual Reformers of the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries3511911HistoryN/AN/A
11/25/25Robert CaroMaster of the Senate
The Years of Lyndon Johnson (3)
12322002History9.0008.889
Carter
11/5/25Robert CaroMeans of Ascent
The Years of Lyndon Johnson (2)
5921990History8.7508.611
Carter
10/16/25Vincent BevinsThe Jakarta Method3202020History4.5003.889
9/26/25Robert CaroThe Path to Power
The Years of Lyndon Johnson (1)
9601982History8.5008.333
Carter
5/7/25Robert CaroThe Power Broker13361974History8.5178.352
Carter
1/16/25Robert CaroThe Passage of Power
The Years of Lyndon Johnson (4)
7682012History8.5008.333
Carter