murphyandhislaw

reading list

The Yiddish Policeman’s Union

Michael Chabon

published: 2007, read: 12/27/23
468 pages, genre: Historical Fiction
rating: 7/10, normalized: 6.667/10
-0.23σ worse than average
-0.547σ or -0.493/10 worse than average in Historical Fiction genre
-0.902σ or -0.197/10 worse than average by Michael Chabon

About 1/4 of the way in so far and I give it an 8/10, I'm really enjoying the premise of this book. The exposition of the characters alongside the alternate history that leads to Alaskan Israel, and the shift in culture of Jewish pessimism is both humorous and dark.

Lots of fun rhetoric, perhaps a bit heavy on the figures of speech at times – almost reading like a caricature of a 60s crime noir novel, but more vulgar than what you'd expect from that time plays well. I really enjoy the repetition of "strange time to be a Jew" which is very reminiscent of Vonnegut's "So it goes" in Slaughterhouse 5.

"The coffee machine hawks and spits like a decrepit Jewish policeman after climbing 10 flights of steps"

and

"A sense of doom indistinguishable from peace"

etc. etc.

Middle half of the book is a bit feverish. Characters don't just teleport around Kamchatka per se, but it kind of feels that way. Several setpieces with no beginning, just middle and end, concatenated to one another.

This middle portion is really good if you already enjoy the crime/thriller genre and the world that's been built so far, but if you get your fix from plot development and more mystery unfolding, the middle 175 pages or so are kind of stagnant. Just Landsman stumbling around getting into trouble, being sad about ex-wife, chasing the case he's not supposed to be working on, and getting out of sticky situations.

The revelation / solidification of the overarching conspiracy leading into the final act is very compelling since it blows the top right off of Sitka and broaches contemporary conflicts which is a kind of funny direction to take the book in. ~Even in alternate timeline, Jews and Arabs will fight over Palestine.

related

ReadAuthorTitlePagesPublishedGenreRatingRating'TagsRecommended by
12/27/23Michael ChabonThe Yiddish Policeman’s Union 4682007Historical Fiction7.0006.667
12/7/24Dan SimmonsThe Rise of Endymion
Hyperion Cantos (4)
5791997Sci-Fi6.0005.556
hetiyl
11/11/24Michael ChabonThe Escapists1602006Graphic Novel7.5007.222
6/7/24Michael ChabonMaps & Legends: Reading & Writing along the Borderlands2002008Essays7.0896.766
7/6/23Dan SimmonsCarrion Comfort8021989Horror8.5638.403
hetiyl
1/9/22Michael LewisThe Undoing Project3682016Biography7.7507.500
hetiyl
8/12/17Kurt VonnegutSlaughterhouse Five1901969Fiction7.7507.500
referenced
Sean G.
7/11/26Kirill EskovThe Gospel of Afranius 2121995Historical Fiction7.8757.639
Mikhail Bulgakov
6/26/26William T. VollmannEurope Central8322005Historical Fiction8.5508.389
2/14/26James A. MichenerCentennial11041974Historical Fiction7.7507.500
Grandpa
12/20/25Joshua WheelerThe High Heaven: A Novel3042025Historical Fiction7.7177.463
12/4/25Thomas PynchonMason & Dixon7731977Historical Fiction8.0007.778
11/23/25Mathias ÉnardTell Them of Battles, Kings and Elephants1442010Historical Fiction7.2006.889
Dasha
10/18/25Shūsaku EndōSilence2561969Historical Fiction8.0007.778
10/7/25Thomas PynchonVineland3851990Historical Fiction7.9007.667
8/30/25James ClavellWhirlwind
Asian Saga (6)
12001986Historical Fiction7.6887.431
5/20/25James ClavellNoble House
Asian Saga (5)
12841981Historical Fiction8.3338.148
2/23/25James ClavellKing Rat
Asian Saga (4)
5441962Historical Fiction7.8007.556
1/28/25Stephen King11/22/638492011Historical Fiction8.0007.778
Grandma
12/30/24James ClavellGai-Jin
Asian Saga (3)
12341993Historical Fiction6.0005.556
10/25/24James ClavellTai-Pan
Asian Saga (2)
8961966Historical Fiction7.9587.731
10/10/24Thomas PynchonGravity's Rainbow8871973Historical Fiction8.5008.333
9/23/24John SteinbeckThe Moon is Down1261942Historical Fiction7.2506.944
9/13/24Abraham VergheseCutting for Stone6582009Historical Fiction7.0506.722
Mom
8/4/24Claire KeeganSmall Things Like These1162020Historical Fiction7.0006.667
6/24/24Umberto EcoThe Name of the Rose6921980Historical Fiction7.7507.500
5/13/24James ClavellShōgun
Asian Saga (1)
12991975Historical Fiction7.5837.315
Jeff W.
2/1/24Neal StephensonCryptonomicon11721999Historical Fiction8.5638.403
9/17/23R. F. KuangThe Poppy War
The Poppy War (1)
6512018Historical Fiction4.3333.704
roon
9/10/23Susan MeissnerThe Nature of Fragile Things3852021Historical Fiction6.2505.833
Mom
10/10/17Naguib MahfouzThe Thief and the Dogs1621961Historical Fiction7.2506.944
Steg