murphyandhislaw

reading list

Asterios Polyp

David Mazzucchelli

published: 2009, read: 8/16/24
346 pages, genre: Graphic Novel
rating: 9.25/10, normalized: 9.167/10
1.814σ better than average
2.943σ or 1.855/10 better than average in Graphic Novel genre

The art is 10/10, it's stylistically dynamic, and Mazzuchelli commands a voice which is so distinct from anything else I've ever read or seen that I couldn't put this book down.

Like many graphic novels, the scenes aen't confined to rigid panels, but the way the author makes use of the page, the negative space, and color to force the charcters' various personalities (some heavily formalistic and dualistic, others more free-spirited) onto the page is masterful. Different characters using different fonts, and even imitating or mocking one another by appropriating their font is so cool and vaguely reminds me of House of Leaves.

Asterios' posed wireframe vs. Hana's hewn figure is so cool. The book is filled with double layers, opposites, and even the occasional triplicate. I also thoroughly enjoyed how well Mazzucchelli is able to bring the "serious" / "highbrow" space of literature into the comic medium. Plays on Greek tragedy, re-imaginations, all the while poking post-modernist fun at the form and format of itself and what it's mocking is so well done. The whole story is ornamented with symbolusm, drawn out across flashbacks where we can see the protagonist's overbearing personality cling onto his diametrical worldview only to have his marraige wrecked by an even more insufferable iteration of his aloof self.

Perhaps confusingly, Asterios is bludgeoned by the version of himself that could have been, and this is what it takes to "assassinate his character" and humble him to the point where Hana might entertain them getting back together. The irony of the conclusion is understated and overstated simultaneously, and not a stroke is wasted on the page.

So good

related

ReadAuthorTitlePagesPublishedGenreRatingRating'TagsRecommended by
8/16/24David MazzucchelliAsterios Polyp3462009Graphic Novel9.2509.167
10/18/24Frank MillerBatman: Year One1441987Graphic Novel8.0007.778
"boy's a liar"
11/10/25David MarksonWittgenstein's Mistress2481988Fiction8.2508.056
mythology
Dasha
9/13/24Abraham VergheseCutting for Stone6582009Historical Fiction7.0506.722
"and they were roommates"
Mom
5/17/24Neil GaimanAmerican Gods5182001Fiction5.1254.583
mythology
Nick W.
5/1/23Ada PalmerPerhaps the Stars
Terra Ignota (4)
8542021Sci-Fantasy9.5009.444
mythology
roon
7/14/16Henry NeffThe Second Siege
Tapestry (2)
5122008Fantasy7.5007.222
mythology
Charlie J.
3/4/16Michael ScottThe Enchantress
The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel (6)
4162012Fantasy7.2506.944
mythology
2/2/16Michael ScottThe Warlock
The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel (5)
4002011Fantasy7.5007.222
mythology
11/10/15Michael ScottThe Necromancer
The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel (4)
4162010Fantasy7.5007.222
mythology
4/20/15Michael ScottThe Sorceress
The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel (3)
4832009Fantasy7.0006.667
mythology
3/13/15Michael ScottThe Magician
The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel (2)
4612008Fantasy7.0006.667
mythology
7/15/14Michael ScottThe Alchemist
The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel (1)
3752007Fantasy6.7506.389
mythology
9/25/26Scott SnyderDevil's Workshop
Absolute Batman (3)
1922026Graphic Novel7.0006.667
9/22/26Scott SnyderAbomination
Absolute Batman (2)
1922025Graphic Novel7.5007.222
10/10/25Scott SnyderThe Zoo
Absolute Batman (1)
1922024Graphic Novel7.0006.667
8/3/25John MurryA Short History of Decay: Sea of Cortez522016Graphic Novel8.0057.783
6/11/25Katsuhisa MinamiThe Fable
The Fable (1)
4152015Graphic Novel6.0005.556
Will C.
5/23/25Alan MooreWatchmen3341986Graphic Novel8.7088.565
5/19/25Yasuki TanakaVolume 6
Summertime Rendering (6)
4802017Graphic Novel6.2505.833
Will C.
5/13/25Yasuki TanakaVolume 5
Summertime Rendering (5)
4332017Graphic Novel6.8506.500
Will C.
4/29/25Yasuki TanakaVolume 4
Summertime Rendering (4)
4252017Graphic Novel7.0006.667
Will C.
3/31/25Yasuki TanakaVolume 3
Summertime Rendering (3)
4112017Graphic Novel7.6007.333
Will C.
3/7/25Yasuki TanakaVolume 2
Summertime Rendering (2)
3782017Graphic Novel7.0006.667
Will C.
2/28/25Yasuki TanakaVolume 1
Summertime Rendering (1)
3522017Graphic Novel7.2506.944
Will C.
1/10/25Christophe ChaboutéPark Bench3362017Graphic Novel7.0006.667
1/9/25Junji ItoUzumaki6482013Graphic Novel7.2506.944
Will C.
11/11/24Michael ChabonThe Escapists1602006Graphic Novel7.5007.222
9/23/24Christophe ChaboutéAlone3842017Graphic Novel7.0006.667
6/13/24Warren EllisBook One
Transmetropolitan (1)
3201997Graphic Novel7.2506.944
Preston
4/12/24Kanehito YamadaBeyond Journey's End (7)1922023Graphic Novel7.5007.222
Will C.
4/11/24Kanehito YamadaBeyond Journey's End (6)1922022Graphic Novel7.5007.222
Will C.
4/10/24Kanehito YamadaBeyond Journey's End (5)1922022Graphic Novel7.5007.222
Will C.
2/7/23Kanehito YamadaBeyond Journey's End (4)1922022Graphic Novel7.5007.222
Will C.
2/6/23Kanehito YamadaBeyond Journey's End (2)2002022Graphic Novel7.5007.222
Will C.
2/6/23Kanehito YamadaBeyond Journey's End (3)2002022Graphic Novel7.5007.222
Will C.
2/2/23Kanehito YamadaBeyond Journey's End (1)1922021Graphic Novel7.5007.222
Will C.
4/20/20Alec RobbinsMr. Boop3842020Graphic Novel7.7507.500